PUBLIC FINANCE ORDINANCE

作者:法律资料网 时间:2024-07-04 15:45:49   浏览:8372   来源:法律资料网
下载地址: 点击此处下载

PUBLIC FINANCE ORDINANCE ——附加英文版

Hong Kong


 PUBLIC FINANCE ORDINANCE
 (CHAPTER 2)
 ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS
  
  ion
  I    PRELIMINARY
  hort title
  nterpretation
  he general revenue
  harges on the general revenue
  II    THE ESTIMATES OF REVENUE AND EXPENDITURE, AND
APPROPRIATION
  nnual estimates
  pproval of estimates of expenditure and appropriation
  uthorization of expenditure in advance of appropriation
  hanges to the approved estimates of expenditure
  upplementary Appropriation
  III   CONTROL AND MANAGEMENT
  General powers and duties of the Financial Secretary
  Power to make regulations and give directions, etc.
  Controlling officers.
  Controlling officers to obey regulations and directions, etc.
  Authority of controlling officers to incur expenditure
  Further authority of controlling officers in respect of urgent
  nditure
  IV    RECEIPT, PAYMENT AND CUSTODY OF PUBLIC MONEYS
  Duties of Director of Accounting Services
  Prompt collection of moneys
  Payment of public moneys
  Payment of certain moneys to be authorized by warrant
  Recoverable advances
  Advances to meet urgent need for payment
  Imprests
  Deposits
  Donations and grants
  Banking
  Investment of moneys
  Borrowing powers and loans
  Guarantees
  Establishment of funds
  Special suspense accounts
  Appropriations and warrants to lapse at close of financial year
  V    SURCHARGE
  Power to surcharge
  Notification of surcharge and right of appeal
  Appeal against surcharge
  Withdrawal of surcharge
  Collection of surcharge
  Surcharge in respect of deceased persons
  VI    MISCELLANEOUS
  Abandonment of claims, etc. and write-off of public moneys and
stores
  Disposal of serviceable stores, etc.
  Power of Governor to give directions
  Director of Accounting Services may give certain directions, etc.
to
  ic officers in receipt of certain moneys
  Trusts
  Transitional
  Effect of dissolution of Legislative Council
  t Schedule. Funds
  nd Schedule. Special Suspense Accounts
 Whole document
  
  rovide for the control and management of the public finances of 
Hong
  and for incidental and connected purposes.
  pril 1983] L. N. 109 of 1983
 PART I PRELIMINARY
  
  hort title
  Ordinance may be cited as the Public Finance Ordinance.
  nterpretation
  his Ordinance, unless the context otherwise requires--
  ropriation Bill" and "Appropriation Ordinance" means a 
Bill or
  nance, as the case may be, which provides for appropriation from 
the
  ral revenue in respect of the approved estimates of expenditure
on the
  ices of the Government for a financial year;
  roved estimates of expenditure" means the estimates of 
expenditure
  ed to be approved under section 6;
  trolling officer" in relation to a head or subhead means the 
officer
  gnated as controlling officer of that head or subhead under 
section
  
  ector of Audit" means the Director of Audit appointed under
section 3
  he Audit Ordinance (Cap. 122);
  ctment" includes an imperial enactment;
  enditure" includes expenditure on the services of the 
Government
  ired to be met under any enactment;
  ance Committee" means the Finance Committee of the Legislative
Council
  blished under the Standing Orders of the Legislative Council;
  eral revenue" means moneys which under this Ordinance or any 
other
  tment are to be paid into or to form part of the general revenue;
  d" means a head of expenditure;
  lic moneys" means--
  the general revenue;
  any moneys which are accounted for in the books or records of 
account
  he Director of Accounting Services; and (Replaced 11 of 1990 s.
2)
  any other moneys which the Governor may declare in writing 
to be
  ic moneys for the purposes of this Ordinance;
  head" means a subhead of expenditure;
  plementary Appropriation Bill" and  "Supplementary 
Appropriation
  nance" means a Bill or Ordinance, as the case may be, which 
provides
  appropriation from the general revenue in supplementation 
of the
  opriation already made by an Appropriation Ordinance.
  he general revenue
  Except where otherwise provided by or under this Ordinance 
or any
  r enactment any moneys raised or received for the purposes 
of the
  rnment shall form part of the general revenue.
  Any refund or drawback may be made from the general 
revenue in
  rdance with regulations made under section 11. (Replaced 8 of 1984 
s.
  
  For the avoidance of doubt it is hereby declared that the
reference in
  ection (1) to moneys raised or received for the purposes 
of the
  rnment does not include moneys held on trust.
  harges on the general revenue
  xpenditure shall be charged on the general revenue except as 
provided
  r under this Ordinance or any other enactment.
 PART II THE ESTIMATES OF REVENUE AND EXPENDITURE, AND APPROPRIA- 
TION
  
  nnual estimates
  The Financial Secretary shall cause to be prepared in each 
financial
  estimates of the revenue and expenditure of the Government for 
the
  following financial year, and shall cause such estimates to be 
laid
  re the Legislative Council before or as soon as practicable after 
the
  encement of the financial year to which they relate.
  Subject to subsection (3), the estimates of revenue and 
expenditure
  l be in such form as the Financial Secretary may from time to 
time
  ct.
  The estimates of expenditure shall--
  classify expenditure under heads and subheads with the ambit of 
each
  described;
  in respect of each head show the estimated total 
expenditure, the
  ision sought in respect of each subhead, the establishment of
posts
  any), and the limit (if any) to the commitments which may be 
entered
  in respect of expenditure which is not annually recurrent; and
  specify the controlling officer designated in respect of each
head and
  ead under section 12.
  Where there is a requirement under any enactment that 
expenditure be
  from the general revenue, provision for such expenditure 
shall be
  uded in the estimates of expenditure for the purposes of this 
Part,
  without prejudice to the validity or effect of any such
requirement.
  pproval of estimates of expenditure and appropriation
  The heads contained in the estimates of expenditure for a 
financial
  shall be included in an Appropriation Bill which shall be 
introduced
  the Legislative Council at the same time as the estimates.
  Upon the enactment of the Appropriation Ordinance the 
estimates of
  nditure for the financial year to which the Ordinance relates
shall be
  ed to be approved to the extent that they are provided for in 
the
  nance and shall have effect from the first day of such financial
year.
  Expenditure for the financial year on the services of the 
Government
  l, subject to this Ordinance, be arranged in accordance with the
heads
  subheads and be limited by the provision in each subhead shown
in the
  mates of expenditure as approved or as may subsequently be 
changed
  time to time in accordance with section 8.
  uthorization of expenditure in advance of appropriation
  The Legislative Council may, in advance of an Appropriation
Ordinance,
  esolution authorize expenditure for the services of the
Government in
  ect of a financial year to be charged on the general 
revenue, in
  rdance with this Ordinance and subject to such 
limitations and
  itions as may be specified in the resolution.
  Expenditure charged on the general revenue pursuant to a 
resolution
  r this section shall be arranged in accordance with the 
heads and
  eads shown in the estimates of expenditure laid under section 
5 and
  provisions of this Ordinance shall, for the purposes 
of this
  ection and subject to such conditions and limitations as 
may be
  ified in the resolution, apply to such estimates as though they 
were
  approved estimates of expenditure.
  Expenditure charged on the general revenue pursuant to a 
resolution
  r this section shall be set off against the amounts 
respectively
  ided in the Appropriation Ordinance upon the same 
coming into
  ation.
  
  hanges to the approved estimates of expenditure
  Subject to this section, no changes shall be made to the 
approved
  mates of expenditure except with the approval of the Finance
Committee
  a proposal of the Financial Secretary.
  Without limiting the generality of subsection (1) such 
changes may
  ide for all or any of the following matters--
  the creation of new heads or subheads;
  supplementary provision in approved or new subheads;
  variations in the establishments of posts;
  increases in the limit to the commitments which may be entered
into in
  ect of expenditure which is not annually recurrent.
  The Finance Committee may delegate to the Financial 
Secretary the
  r to approve changes subject to such conditions, 
exceptions and
  tations as are specified in the delegation.
  The Financial Secretary, where a delegation by the Finance 
Committee
  r subsection (3) so provides, and subject to such 
conditions,
  ptions and limitations as are specified in the delegation, may
further
  gate his power to approve changes to any public officer.
  A delegation to any public officer under subsection (4) 
shall be
  ect to such further conditions, exceptions and limitations 
as the
  ncial Secretary may specify.
  Nothing in subsection (1) shall be construed as 
limiting  or
  cting--
  the power of the Governor to make any proposal, or allow or direct
any
  osal to be made, to the Legislative Council, the object or effect 
of
  h is to require a change to the approved estimates of expenditure;
or
  a requirement under any enactment that expenditure be met 
from the
  ral revenue.
  The Financial Secretary shall cause such changes to be made 
to the
  oved estimates of expenditure as are necessary in respect of any--
  approval given under subsection (1), (3) or (4);
  expenditure pursuant to a proposal referred to in subsection (6) 
(a);
  
  requirement referred to in subsection (6) (b) not otherwise 
provided
  by approval under this section.
  The Financial Secretary shall at the end of each quarter 
of the
  ncial year or as soon as practicable thereafter--
  report to the Finance Committee changes made to the approved
estimates
  xpenditure in that quarter upon approval by him or by any 
public
  cer pursuant to a delegation under section (3) or (4), as the case
may
  and
  table in the Legislative Council a summary of all changes made
to the
  oved estimates of expenditure in that quarter under this section.
  Without prejudice to section 9, expenditure in respect of 
which a
  ge to the approved estimates is made under this section 
shall be
  ged on the general revenue notwithstanding that there has 
been no
  opriation in respect thereof by an Appropriation Ordinance.
  upplementary Appropriation
  t the close of account for any financial year it is 
found that
  nditure charged to any head is in excess of the sum appropriated 
for
  head by an Appropriation Ordinance, the excess shall be included
in a
  lementary Appropriation Bill which shall be introduced 
into the
  slative Council as soon as practicable after the close 
of the
  ncial year to which the excess expenditure relates.
 PART III CONTROL AND MANAGEMENT
  
  General powers and duties of the Financial Secretary
  Financial Secretary shall, subject to this Ordinance and any 
other
  tment, have the management of the finances of the Government and 
the
  rvision, control and direction of all matters relating 
to the
  ncial affairs of the Government.
  Power to make regulations and give directions, etc.
  Without prejudice to any other provision of this 
Ordinance, the
  ncial Secretary may make such administrative regulations and give
such
  nistrative directions and instructions not inconsistent 
with this
  nance as may appear to him to be necessary or expedient for the
better
  ying out of the provisions and purposes of this Ordinance and for 
the
  ty, economy and advantage of public moneys and Government
property.
  Any regulations made or directions and instructions given 
by the
  rnor or by any person authorized by him, for purposes similar to
those
  espect of which regulations, directions and instructions may be 
made
  iven under subsection (1), and which are in force at the 
commencement
  his Ordinance, shall, in so far as they are not inconsistent with
this
  nance, remain in force and shall be deemed for all purposes to 
have
  made or given under this section and to be liable to revocation 
or
  dment hereunder.
  Controlling officers
  Estimates of expenditure laid before the Legislative Council 
shall
  gnate a controlling officer in respect of each head and subhead.
  Subject to section 14 (5), a controlling officer shall be 
responsible
  accountable for all expenditure from any head or subhead for which 
he
  he controlling officer, and for all public moneys and 
Government
  erty in respect of the department or service for 
which he is
  onsible.
  Controlling officers to obey regulations and directions, etc.
  y controlling officer shall obey all regulations made and 
directions
  nstructions given by the Financial Secretary under section 
11 and
  l, if so required, account to the Financial Secretary 
for the
  ormance of his duties as controlling officer.
  Authority of controlling officers to incur expenditure
  Subject to any regulations made or directions or instructions
given by
  Financial Secretary under section 11 and to any reservation 
made by
  Financial Secretary under subsection (3), a controlling officer 
may,
  accordance with this Ordinance, incur expenditure and 
authorize
  nditure to be incurred against any provision shown in any subhead 
for
  h he is the controlling officer.
  No expenditure shall be incurred against any provision shown 
in any
  ead except by or under the authority of the controlling officer.
  The Financial Secretary may, in writing, reserve the whole or any
part
  ny provision shown in any subhead and for so long as such 
reservation
  ins in force no expenditure shall be incurred against the 
provision
  rved.
  A controlling officer may, in respect of any subhead for which 
he is
  controlling officer, by allocation warrant signed by him or 
by a
  ic officer authorized generally or specially by him, 
authorize any
  r controlling officer to incur expenditure or authorize
expenditure to
  ncurred against any provision shown in that subhead--(Added 8 of
1984
  )
  for any purpose within the ambit of that subhead; and
  in accordance with the terms of the allocation warrant.
  The controlling officer to whom an allocation warrant is issued 
under
  ection (4) shall be responsible and accountable for any 
expenditure
  rred under the warrant as if he were the controlling 
officer
  gnated in respect thereof under section 12.
  
  Further authority of controlling officers in respect 
of urgent
  nditure
  where an urgent need has arisen for expenditure to be incurred
which--
  requires a change to the approved estimates of expenditure in 
respect
  atters referred to in section 8 (2) (b) or (d); and
  in the opinion of a controlling officer cannot be deferred until 
the
  ssary change is made in accordance with section 8 without 
serious
  iment to the public interest, the controlling officer may, 
on his
  onal responsibility, incur the expenditure in anticipation 
of such
  ge.
  As soon as practicable after incurring expenditure under
subsection
  the controlling officer shall report the matter to the 
Financial
  etary for the purpose of having the necessary change made 
to the
  oved estimates of expenditure.
  Where the necessary change to the approved estimates of
expenditure is
  made in accordance with section 8, the expenditure incurred shall 
not
  charged on the general revenue but shall remain the 
personal
  onsibility of the controlling officer who incurred the 
expenditure.
 PART IV RECEIPT, PAYMENT AND CUSTODY OF PUBLIC MONEYS
  
  Duties of Director of Accounting Services
  The Director of Accounting Services shall be responsible 
for the
  ilation and supervision of the accounts of the Government, 
for the
  gement of accounting operations and procedures, and for ensuring 
that
  regulations directions or instructions made or given 
under this
  nance relating thereto and in respect of the safe custody of 
public
  ys and its accounting are complied with.
  Without prejudice to the generality of his duties under
subsection (1)
  the powers conferred on the Financial Secretary by section 
11 the
  ctor of Accounting Services shall--
  ensure that adequate arrangements are made for bringing 
promptly and
  erly to account all public moneys received and paid by the
Government;
  pay such sums from public moneys as he is authorized to pay under
this
  nance or any other enactment;
  ensure, in so far as is practicable, that adequate 
arrangements are
  for the safe custody of public moneys; and
  bring to the notice of the Financial Secretary and the 
Director of
  t, in writing, any material defect in departmental control of
revenue,
  nditure, cash, stamps, securities, stores and other 
Government
  erty which may come to his notice and any persistent 
breaches of
  lations, directions or instructions made or given 
under  this
  nance.
  Subject to the provisions of any enactment, in the exercise 
of his
  es the Director of Accounting Services shall be entitled to 
inspect
  offices and shall have access to all records, books, 
vouchers

不分页显示   总共3页  1 [2] [3]

  下一页

下载地址: 点击此处下载

合肥市财政局关于印发《合肥市社会培训单位从事会计类培训申报备案办法》的通知

安徽省合肥市财政局


关于印发《合肥市社会培训单位从事会计类培训申报备案办法》的通知

合财会[2007]106号


各县区财政局,各有关单位:

为进一步规范合肥市会计培训市场,提高培训质量,维护广大会计从业人员的合法利益,根据《会计从业资格管理办法》和《会计人员继续教育规定》等有关规定,特制定《合肥市社会培训单位从事会计类培训申报备案办法》,现予印发,请遵照执行。



二○○七年四月二十九日



附件:合肥市社会培训单位从事会计类培训申报备案办法


合肥市社会培训单位
从事会计类培训申报备案办法

第一章 总 则
第一条 为进一步规范合肥市会计培训市场,提高培训质量,维护广大会计从业人员的合法利益,根据《会计从业资格管理办法》和《会计人员继续教育规定》等有关规定,制定本办法。
第二条 凡按本办法申报,经市财政局备案的会计培训单位,将在市财政局网站上予以公布。
第三条 市财政局定期对培训单位进行评估管理和监督检查,并将相关内容和结果以适当方式向社会公布。
第二章 会计培训资格的申报备案
第四条 培训单位申报的基本条件
(一)自愿接受和配合市财政局做好会计人员培训工作;
(二)严格遵守会计人员继续教育规定;
(三)具备承担培训工作相适应的一定规模及固定的教学场所和设施;
(四)拥有与承担培训工作相适应的教学和管理人员;
(五)有严密的教学管理制度;
(六)独立核算的具有法人资格的单位或经济实体,有办学许可证或营业执照,且营业范围包括有会计类培训内容;
(七)培训收费标准已报物价部门备案,且向学员的收费能出具正规的收费票据。
第五条 申办单位应按规定程序进行申请并提供相应的申报材料:
(一)合肥市社会培训单位从事会计类培训登记备案表;
(二)社会团体法人登记证、办学许可证、组织机构代码证复印件(核对原件);
(三)法人代表身份证复印件;
(四)已在物价部门备案的收费标准复印件;
(五)办公、教学场地产权或者使用权有效证明复印件;
(六)申请单位的基本情况说明、教学管理制度;
(七)专职教学人员的基本情况及教师资格证书、职称证书复印件;
(八)财政部门要求的其他材料。
第六条 市财政局根据申报材料,进行核实确认,符合条件的予以登记备案。
第三章 培训管理
第七条 培训单位必须接受市财政局的指导、监督和检查。
第八条 培训单位要针对不同级别会计人员和不同培训内容安排相应的授课教师,将教学人员的资料报市财政局备案。
第九条 培训单位要按照财政部门制定的学习内容编印教材。
第十条 培训单位在每期培训班开办前,要将培训内容、教学计划、培训时间、人数、授课教师等事项,填写培训情况说明书,报送市财政局。
第十一条 培训单位要按照规定的内容和课时,保质保量完成教学培训工作,不准随意缩减课时和更改教学大纲。
第十二条 培训单位必须在规定的培训地点对培训对象进行教学培训工作,不得随意更改教学场所,不得向外扩展分点,也不得将培训工作转托其他单位。
第十三条 要严格按照物价部门规定的收费标准收费,不得擅自提高标准。
第十四条 培训单位制定服务承诺书(送财政局备案),在各培训点张榜公开,听取学员意见,并设立投诉电话。
第十五条 培训单位在每期培训班结束后,按规定格式将培训人员名单(含软盘)和考勤情况表报送市财政局。
第四章 监督指导和整改
第十六条 市财政局将采取在培训场所设立监督举报箱,公布举报电话、不定期现场抽查等方式对培训单位进行监督和考核,并将检查、评估结果以适当方式向社会公布。
第十七条 培训单位有下列情况之一的,限期改正:
(一) 随意缩减课时和更改教学内容;
(二) 随意更改教学场所和更换教师的;
(三) 未按规定履行服务承诺的;
(四) 未按时报送培训情况说明书等财政部门要求的有关材料的;
第十八条 培训单位有下列情况之一的,由继续教育主管部门予以通报:
(一)有上述第十六条所列情况,未能在限期内整改的;
(二)未在规定的培训地点对培训对象进行培训工作,擅自向外扩展分点,扩大培训范围,将培训工作转托其他单位的;
(三)学员投诉多,教学质量低劣,教学管理混乱的;
(四)未按第八条规定,任用不具有专业技术资格的教学人员的;
(五)发现有弄虚作假行为的;
(六)有其他违法法律法规行为的。
第五章 附 则
第十九条 本办法由合肥市财政局负责解释。
第二十条 本办法自发布之日起执行。


附表1:
合肥市社会培训单位从事会计类培训登记备案表
培训项目类型: 填写日期:
单位名称(盖章):
分支机构名称: 法人代表:
分支机构负责人:
注册地址: 办公地址:
电话: 联系人:
管理人员人数: 人 教师人数: 人
法人代表手机:
联系人手机:
教学地址:
教学面积:
产权关系: 计算机数量、型号:

附表2:
管理人员基本情况登记表
姓 名 出生年月 学历 职 称 是否
专职 固定电话:
手机: 备注












附表3:
教师基本情况登记表
姓名 单 位 学历 职称 是否
专职 固定电话:
手机: 备注













核心提示:许霆案、何鹏案属于民法调整的范畴,既有客观事实依据,又有明确的法律依据。

现代银行通常以省为单位,设立一台银行服务器作为核心,全省营业网点的窗口电脑和自动柜员机都是终端,终端与服务器相联接组成现代银行的二元化结构。

客户在窗口要求柜员办理银行业务,与客户在柜员机上自助操作,性质上是一样的,都是向银行提出自己的请求,终端会将请求传递给银行服务器。银行服务器是无人值守、自动响应的,当收到终端传递过来的客户请求后,服务器自动将保存在数据库中的客户账户资料调出来,然后根据请求自动运行存款程序、取款程序办理银行业务。服务器办好银行业务后会向终端发出收取存款、支付取款指令,由银行营业窗口的柜员人工执行或者柜员机自动执行。银行服务器与自动柜员机配合,就实现了银行服务无人化。

客户取款,银行要对客户是否满足取款的二个条件进行判断:一是对客户提供的密码与账户留存的密码是否匹配相符;二是账户余额与请求取款数额的差值是否不小于1。判断第一个条件是否相符,其含义是银行核对取款人的身份。当输入的密码正确时发生取款交易,视为账户本人的交易行为。只有通过输入正确的密码,银行电脑系统才会允许进入系统并有资格提出取款请求。如果密码不正确,则会被银行电脑系统拒之门外,要求重新输入密码。判断第二个条件是否相符,其含义是银行要求取款后账户余额数字不得小于1。请求取款的数额必须少于原来的余额,且新的余额数字不得小于1。当原来的余额与请求取款数额之差小于1时,则服务器向终端返回信息,余额不足,交易失败;当原来的余额与请求取款数额之差不小于1时,则服务器自动运行取款程序,扣除此次取款数额得出新的余额,作好取款记录,然后向终端发出支付取款的指令。

不难看出,客户到银行取款,是否符合银行取款条件,需要银行电脑系统进行判断并作出决定(相当于银行管理者的大脑思维),这个判断及决定后的操作,集中体现银行的意志,所以,银行电脑系统具有简单的意识,能独立代表银行意志与客户进行交易,事中不需要有人参与其中,事后也不需要有人审核。电脑知道,代表银行知道。“机器知道,人不知道”是现代银行的运行模式。

针对取款的第一个条件——账户与密码匹配相符。与陈兴良、张明楷取款时完全一样,何鹏、许霆输入正确密码时,银行电脑系统已经识别何鹏、许霆的身份。从这个时候起,双方的取款交易是公开的,毫无秘密性可言。

针对取款的第二个条件——账户余额与请求取款数额的差值不小于1。陈兴良、张明楷取款时,账户余额和请求取款数额,与实际情况相符,都没有出现差错,跟大家日常遇到的情况完全一样,属于正常状况。

问题是何鹏、许霆账户中没有这么多的存款,又是如何满足取款的第二个条件取出款来呢?第二个条件就是一个不等式,银行服务器对不等式是否成立进行判断(大脑思维)之前,先要从外界获取账户余额和请求取款数额这两个参数。账户余额保存在银行的数据库中,银行服务器需要时会自动提取;请求取款数额需要从终端输入后传递到银行服务器。由于银行服务器所使用的前述两个参数,都是电子数据,电子数据具有易变性,在保存和传递过程中,由于银行管理上疏失,电子数据可能发生意想不到的变化。这样一来,即使没有那么多的存款,也可能满足取款的第二个条件——不等式成立,从而取出超过实际存款余额的钱来。何鹏案,许霆案就是实例。

对于何鹏案,银行保存在数据库中的何鹏账户余额实际只有10元,是以电子数据的形式保存的。银行在对数据库进行升级时,因管理上疏失,有多种原因,例如格式不对,所保存的电子数据就会发生变化,既可能被充值,也可能被减值。何鹏的账户被充值,由10元变成了100万元。当何鹏提出取款2000元的请求时,银行服务器从数据库中调取的存款余额为100万,银行服务器在判断不等式是否成立时,大脑思维并没有错误,因自身原因获取了错误的参数而产生重大误解,结果不等式成立,从而使银行与何鹏之间达成了取款交易,银行支付了取款给何鹏。

对于许霆案,账户余额中只有176.97元,当许霆提出取款1000元或2000元的请求时,因其账户余额不足,正常状况下是取不出款来的。可是自动柜员机程序升级时因疏忽而留下程序瑕疵,在自动柜员机向银行服务器传递取款请求的过程中,许霆取款1000元或2000元的请求,因程序瑕疵的存在而发生变化,变为许霆取款1元或2元的请求,与实际相比发生了减值,报送到银行服务器。银行服务器在判断不等式是否成立时,大脑思维也没有发生错误,因自身原因获取了错误的参数而产生重大误解,导致不等式成立,从而双方达成取款交易,银行必须支付取款给许霆。在支付取款的过程中,因涉案自动柜员机具有独特的付款机制,又发生了给付错误。

所谓独特的付款机制,指自动柜员机的付款机构被设计有二个开关,第一个开关决定付款数额,第二个开关是否决定付款。因自动柜员机付款必须是整数,当客户输入取款数额后,柜员机将计算取款数额除以100的商值,然后判断商值是否为整数,若不是整数,则要求重新输入,若是整数,则相当于打开了自动柜员机付款机构的第一个开关。第二个开关掌握在银行服务器的取款程序中,一旦前述不等式成立,则银行服务器自动运行取款程序,从账户余额中扣除取款得出新的余额,作好取款记录,然后对自动柜员机发出同意支付的指令。这个同意支付的指令就是自动柜员机付款机构的第二个开关,即决定付款。

许霆案中,银行服务器从账户余额中扣除取款1元或2元,意味着银行同意付款1元或2元给许霆,向自动柜员机发出付款的指令。柜员机收到指令后等于打开了第二个开关,启动了付款机构,可是付款数额又取决于第一个开关,结果银行本意是支付1元或2元的,实际支付的金额却是1000元或2000元,发生给付错误。

何鹏、许霆的取款行为,与陈兴良、张明楷的取款行为一样,银行在判断取款条件是否成立时(大脑思维),并没有错误,同样满足银行设定的取款条件,体现了银行意志。只不过,何鹏、许霆取款时,银行因重大误解体现的并不是其真实意志而已。银行方面清楚是与何鹏、许霆进行交易,不存在秘密性。银行因自身原因,对何鹏的存款余额产生重大误解而与何鹏达成221次交易,成立221份可撤销的储蓄合同,应由民法调整。银行因自身原因,对许霆的取款请求产生重大误解而与之达成171次取款交易,且在交易过程中又发生给付错误,同样成立171份可撤销的储蓄合同,也应由民法调整。根据《电子银行业务管理办法》第89条和《支付结算办法》第215条规定,何鹏案、许霆案的情形,应由银行自行负责,归属于民法调整的范畴,具有明确的法律依据。

作者单位:城步苗族自治县人民检察院 肖佑良


参考资料:
1、《客观事实证明许霆案是错案》
2、《〈客观事实证明许霆案是错案〉的解读》
3、《许霆案解密:银行隐瞒事实铸成大错》
4、《许霆案,虚构的盗窃案》
5、《许霆案•何鹏案•葫芦案》或《许霆案、何鹏案新解,统一歧见的希望》
6、《许霆案何鹏案争议大结局》